Three categories of purchase consistently disappoint on our record. Each has a specific reason.
Keyboard-and-mouse sets. We have reviewed nine gaming keyboard-and-mouse sets. They average 7.24 out of 10, none reach 8.5, and two score below 7.0. Seven of the nine reviews record membrane switches. Eight record ABS keycaps that shine. Four criticise the bundled mouse.
The value praised in all nine reviews is real, but it is the value of getting two things at once rather than the value of getting two good things.
The only set to score 8.0 or above is Logitech's G305 and G413 pairing at 8.3, and that is two products also sold separately.
Buying them separately lets you choose the better board and the better mouse independently, which is what our record suggests you do.
The mechanical-feel trap. Seventeen of our gaming keyboard and keyboard-set reviews record membrane switches. Six of those reviews say the product's marketing or branding implies a mechanical board. Three Amazon listing titles we reviewed say mechanical feel or mechanical feeling on boards our reviews record as membrane. Every standalone membrane keyboard we can price and have scored sits in the cheaper half of our keyboard record.
How to spot a membrane board in ten seconds. Look at the listing title and description. If it says feel, feeling or membrane, and never names a switch type or a switch maker (Gateron, Cherry, Kailh, Huano, TTC, Omron), treat it as membrane. A mechanical keyboard will always name the switch, because the switch is a selling point. If the listing says mechanical feel and gives no switch name, it is almost certainly membrane. Our
Logitech G213 Prodigy review (7.0) is the clearest example: the board carries Mech-Dome branding and our review records it as not a mechanical keyboard. The
RedThunder K10 keyboard-and-mouse set review (7.5) is another: the Amazon listing says mechanical feel and our review records membrane switches. If you want a real mechanical board at a lower price, our
budget mechanical keyboards guide is the honest route.
Surround-sound badges. Our record is split exactly: 7 headset reviews count virtual surround or spatial audio as a plus and 7 say virtual 7.1 degrades or adds nothing to positional audio.
One review, our HyperX Cloud II review, says both about the same headset: it counts the USB adaptor's virtual surround as a feature and records that the 7.1 mode degrades competitive positional accuracy.
Of the 77 gaming headsets currently in our priced catalogue, 16 carry surround or spatial wording in the listing name. The badge tells you nothing reliable.
Judge a headset on its drivers, tuning and comfort, and treat any surround mode as something to switch off if it muddies footsteps. The 21 reviews that record a narrow soundstage or weak positional audio are not helped by a software mode layered on top.